User talk:Hanryu: Difference between revisions
(Welcome and Shop Pages) |
(Beseech articles/quest info) |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
A note about shop pages, since I see you've added a missing shop from [[Hara'jaal]]. Have a look at [[A Bit For Horses]] for an example shop, and see [[:Category talk:Shops]] for a run-through on shop page set up. Let me know if you have any questions |
A note about shop pages, since I see you've added a missing shop from [[Hara'jaal]]. Have a look at [[A Bit For Horses]] for an example shop, and see [[:Category talk:Shops]] for a run-through on shop page set up. Let me know if you have any questions |
||
:--[[User:Naeya|Naeya]] <sup>([[User talk:Naeya|talk]])</sup> 11:12, 4 May 2007 (CDT) |
:--[[User:Naeya|Naeya]] <sup>([[User talk:Naeya|talk]])</sup> 11:12, 4 May 2007 (CDT) |
||
== Beseech articles/quest info == |
|||
Hey Hanryu, I was skimming through some of the Beseech articles you've been fleshing out, nice work updating the info there. I'm concerned about two things though. You've given instructions on how to solve some of the quests. I don't play a Ranger, and I don't know--is that info considered an in-game secret? Walk-throughs are very useful but the general policy here is not to reveal secrets or spoilers on a main article page since that could spoil things for someone who wants to figure it out on their own, and only came to the article seeking general information. |
|||
A good way to include secret info is to make a sub-page of the main article, eg [[Beseech Water to Solidify/Quest walkthrough]] and put the info there, with a link from the main article. |
|||
My second concern is that the tone of some of your notes on the beseeches is a bit, shall we say, passionate ;) eg. the notes for [[Beseech the Dark to Sing]]. When writing articles take a moment to consider whether what you are writing is fact or opinion. --[[User:Farman|Farman]] 16:27, 20 October 2007 (CDT) |
|||
Revision as of 15:27, 20 October 2007
Welcome and Shop Pages
Welcome to Elanthipedia! If you need anything, feel free to leave a note on my talk page, at our contributors list, or via my pigeon at EmpathNaeya.
A note about shop pages, since I see you've added a missing shop from Hara'jaal. Have a look at A Bit For Horses for an example shop, and see Category talk:Shops for a run-through on shop page set up. Let me know if you have any questions
Beseech articles/quest info
Hey Hanryu, I was skimming through some of the Beseech articles you've been fleshing out, nice work updating the info there. I'm concerned about two things though. You've given instructions on how to solve some of the quests. I don't play a Ranger, and I don't know--is that info considered an in-game secret? Walk-throughs are very useful but the general policy here is not to reveal secrets or spoilers on a main article page since that could spoil things for someone who wants to figure it out on their own, and only came to the article seeking general information.
A good way to include secret info is to make a sub-page of the main article, eg Beseech Water to Solidify/Quest walkthrough and put the info there, with a link from the main article.
My second concern is that the tone of some of your notes on the beseeches is a bit, shall we say, passionate ;) eg. the notes for Beseech the Dark to Sing. When writing articles take a moment to consider whether what you are writing is fact or opinion. --Farman 16:27, 20 October 2007 (CDT)