Player suggestions for Crafting

Spawning from This post by GM Zadraes on the official Discord Binu and I (Mahtra) collated the suggestions that players made in that thread, we cleaned them up, re-worded and merged them. The Impact Rating field is entirely subjective, based on our opinion at the time this page is created. Where possible, names of those who suggested were kept, unless multiple people suggested the same/similar things.

Alchemy

Player Suggestions for Crafting

From	suggestion	impact rating	related craft	Notes
Multiple people	Add herbs to societies: Blue Flowers, Hulij Leaves, Dioica Sap, Belradi Moss, qun pollen (also normalize blue/red flowers across all societies)	high - allows progression of training	Remedies
Binu/CU	Allow crafting of Mortars, bellows, clamps, bowls, and any tool a player may need for crafting	High - some items can be hard to find, raising the barrier of entry into these professions	Remedies, forging
Multiple people	Herb to cure disease. Combo herbs for wounds the way we have cebi and hisan for scars."	high - Help necros out here low	Remedies	marram, flamestalk, dioica, and belradi released and cover all wounds and scars. Two MT options that cover all wounds/scars as well. Necromancer spell Resection released which gives necromancer a way to self-cure disease, reducing the priority for a herb option.
Hanryu	Allow foraging in all rooms with presses/grinders for herbs.	medium - If I had to choose, I'd rather have the herbs available in societies, but this is an either/or to that in a way.	Remedies
Kythryn	Release uncommon, rare and very rare base herbs to increase the potency & efficacy of current Remedy patterns.	low - not needed for training however the discipline doesn't have much variation in results except based off skill & catalysts.	Remedies
Kythryn	Offer a technique that allows freshly foraged herbs to offer a small amount of healing (ala. the old foraging system)	low - not needed for training however in the past, being able to forage and eat your own herbs immediately was a "gateway", promoting an interest into Alchemy.	Remedies

Enchanting

Player Suggestions for Crafting

From	suggestion	impact rating	related craft	Notes
Vlachodimos	Add at least one Tier 12 recipe to artificing. There's currently none and it makes learning in the 1500+ range much slower and impossible to get hard work orders at that point too	high - allows progression of training	Enchanting	TT216 adds a T12 recipe, but doesn't address the core of this request, since braziers can't really be used in workorders.
Mahtra	Enchanting could do with a speed brazier template. Enchanting could do with not requiring sigil farming (which is extremely painful at the top tiers) The sigil minigame is neat and all, but punishing too.	low - brings braziers in line with other tools that have speed and quality templates	Enchanting	Done in TT216
Multiple people	Add secondary sigils to enchanting societies	high - allows progression of training	Enchanting	Done in TT131
Inneth	Perceiving sigils whilst remaining invisible please	low - Can have Social Outrage implications	enchanting	TT131 allows harvesting whilst invisible, which is immensely appreciated. This ask is to bring `perc sigil` in line with `perc mana` which can be done wholly whilst invisible.
Kali	Make Shard supply room crate items match Crossing - specifically the wand.	Low - QOL increase but not system-breaking	Enchanting
Zorthuric	Bring back astral guide creation	Low - Cool Factor	Enchanting

Engineering

Player Suggestions for Crafting

From	suggestion	impact rating	related craft	Notes
Multiple people	Carving lockpicks brought into Engineering	medium - Thief lockpick carving is a wasted "class" thing at the moment.	Engineering
Multiple people	Allow reclamation of crafted materials, such as Stone, bone, leather, cloth	Medium - This is extremely frustrating, especially for rarer materials. So much wastage.	Carving/Tailoring
Multiple people	Allow combining of Stone pieces	Medium - This is extremely frustrating, especially for rarer materials. So much wastage.	Carving/Tailoring
Scrounger	bone and stone tools	low - Carving knives specifically are just terrible in both bone/stone. Lots of options here for tools templates, plenty of unused and unusable bone/stone	all
Kythryn	Engineering wand	low - a forge wand but with a table saw & gear press instead. Alternately, update new forge wands so you can TURN them to choose which set of tools you want (forge, engineering, outfitting or alchemy) that mirror the stationary ones at the crafting halls.	Engineering	Released as MT item.

Forging

Player Suggestions for Crafting

From	suggestion	impact rating	related craft	Notes
Binu/CU	Allow crafting of Mortars, bellows, clamps, bowls, and any tool a player may need for crafting	High - some items can be hard to find, raising the barrier of entry into these professions	Remedies, forging
Multiple people	Do something with advanced marks. Maybe an automated system for people to choose "custom" marks like 2021 HE's gift?	low - This might be a neat TT by itself, but in terms of things broken in crafting... this is low priority	Forging
Hanryu	Renta-forge (instanced forges) in all locations	medium	Forging	Looks to have been done across multiple TTs. Tracked at Crafting_halls
Kythryn	Different renta-forge (instanced forges) portals from free access	medium	Forging	At least in the case of the Shard forge, the rent-forge portals are "doors" and the standard free portals are also a "door". So if you are not paying attention and just "go door", instead of say "go hickory door" and you have the coin on you, you just pop into the rentable one. I'd like to see either the rent ones turned into some other portal type (ie. arch, gap, alcove, etc.) or have a short confirmation RT placed on entering so you need to do a confirm "go door" if you want the rent space instead of the free one.
Hanryu	T12 armorsmithing products at 100 vols or less	high	Forging	Done in TT190

Outfitting

Player Suggestions for Crafting

From	suggestion	impact rating	related craft	Notes
Multiple people	Allow reclamation of crafted materials, such as Stone, bone, leather, cloth	Medium - This is extremely frustrating, especially for rarer materials. So much wastage.	Carving/Tailoring
Multiple people	Allow combining of Stone pieces	Medium - This is extremely frustrating, especially for rarer materials. So much wastage.	Carving/Tailoring

All & Multiple Disciplines

Player Suggestions for Crafting

From	suggestion	impact rating	related craft	Notes
Nideya	Increase access to, and availability of rare materials	low - "would be nice if"	all
Multiple people	RT reductions (with commensurate rewards reductions?)	low - this would just be nice to have at this stage	all
Scrounger	Custom recipe books so we can scribe commonly used patterns and not need to carry all books around all the time.	low - This could be an awesome MT item...	all
Malkien	Carreer/Hobby reset option	medium - QoL for incomplete systems	all	Done in TT140
Binu/CU	Craftable consumables (pins, oil, lotion, stain, hilts, etc). These not being master crafted causes problems with the higher tier templates combined with low workability materials.	high - high tier recipes are impossible without	multiple crafts	New HE447 shop More Tool You provides some access to better consumables. No crafted option yet as of HE447
Binu/CU	Separate registers (or sections in the main register) for leather, cloth, bone, stone, wood, and metal.	medium - Akin to other games having crafting dedicated containers	multiple crafts
Hanryu	Crafting buffs should operate like all other buffs. ie: fix the bug where they _show_ 20% in exp mods, but are actually only 1/2 strength	high	multiple crafts