Dreamheart/Comparison Chart of Stonebows

From Elanthipedia
< Dreamheart
Revision as of 20:58, 9 January 2021 by DREAMWEAVER (talk | contribs) (Added Lobbing Stonebow, Lightened, with Icesteel Mechs ~D.D.)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Notes about using this chart:

  • I did not make all the stonebows in the tinkering book; I only made the weapon models from the Tinkering products page that are considered Advanced (from the Tech names).
  • Affinity seems to be the singular property of any wood in relationship to the combat properties of a finished piece.
  • To save time/coins, I only laminated once during the test crafting. The better construction value will always be because the stonebow is laminated. It does not impact the rest of the stats. Keep that in mind as you review the chart.
  • I made at least two levels of affinity for each stonebow model, 85 and 95 affinity.
  • I made two different mechanisms for each stonebow/wood/style, one at either end of the ductility values. Usually, darkstone (20) or Nickel/Brass (both 90)
    • Ductility does not have seem to make a large difference from 90 down to 31. You need to get under 30 for it to change. Whether this is fractional, too, I have no idea. But 31-96 ductility ... seems to yield the exact same results in the mechs.
    • Ductility in the mechanisms below 30 results in -2 to balance and +1 to suitedness
  • Loading time is from hand, without any penalties. Where there is a decimal value, that is an average of 25 loads (sometimes more, but even with a script, it is as tedious as watching paint dry). The average should give you an idea whether a stonebow will have more 4 second loads than 5 second ones. There is a definite difference, depending on the mods and mechs.
  • Loading time with a notation of anything point zero means every single load time was the same.
  • Expect the load time to vary +/- .2 for any given average.
  • The Points column is the sum of FOI, BALANCE, and SUITEDNESS
  • There is no draw strength listed here because it is not part of stonebow appraisal
  • When a stonebow has been modified by cabling or lightening, and the appraisal stays the same, it is because the difference is fractional.
  • Lightening adds to balance, removes from suitedness (always, even if only fractional), shaves off a few stones, and usuall impacts the draw, too.
  • Cable-backing adds to suitedness, removes from balances, (always, even if only fractional), adds a few stones, and ... usually impacts the draw, too.
  • lam = laminated
  • cab = cable-backed
  • li=lightened

Remember:
FOI impacts damage potential
Balance = Accuracy
Suitedness affects the power in the hit
(With your skills, stats, and situation all getting mixed in.)

If there is a (+1) on an appraisal value, it shows up in the compare only, as being 1 better than the other version. Used (so far) only for 90 and 95 ductility compares. This is what I mean when I tell you there are mods that can be built into these which become fractional and do not show up in the appraisal.

Weapon Name Affin-Wood #Pieces Mod/s Mechs FOI Balance Suited Construction Weight Load RT Points
Lobbing stonebow 85-Lelori 9 no 90 09-well 07-reasonably 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 68 5.72 24
Lobbing stonebow 85-Lelori 9 lam 90 09-well 07-reasonably 08-soundly 05-particularly weak against damage 68 5.84 24
Lobbing stonebow 85-Lelori 9 lam, cab 90 09-well 07-reasonably 08-soundly 05-particularly weak against damage 72 6.0 24
Lobbing stonebow 85-Lelori 9 li 90 09-well 08-soundly 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 65 5.28 24
Lobbing stonebow 85-Lelori 9 no 20 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 68 5.72 23
Lobbing stonebow 85-Lelori 9 cab 20 09-well 05-fairly 09-well 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 72 6.0 23
Lobbing stonebow 85-Lelori 9 li 20 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 65 5.32 23
Lobbing stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 no 90 09-well 08-soundly 09-well 05-particularly weak 71 5.71 26
Lobbing stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 no 95 09-well 08-soundly (+1) 09-well 05-particularly weak 71 5.71 26
Lobbing stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam 95 09-well 08-soundly (+1) 09-well 09-average 71 5.6 26
Lobbing stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 li, lam 95 09-well 09-well 08-soundly 09-average 68 5.17 26
Alpine stonebow 85-Lelori 9 no 90 08-soundly 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 68 5.28 22
Alpine stonebow 85-Lelori 9 li 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 65 5.0 23
Alpine stonebow 85-Sandalwood 9 no 90 08-soundly 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 102 5.36 22
Alpine stonebow 85-Sandalwood 9 lam 90 08-soundly 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 102 5.28 22
Alpine stonebow 85-Sandalwood 9 lam, cab 90 08-soundly 07-reasonably 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 106 5.68 23
Alpine stonebow 85-Sandalwood 9 li 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 99 5.0 23
Alpine stonebow 85-Lelori 9 no 20 08-soundly 06-decently 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 68 5.32 22
Alpine stonebow 85-Lelori 9 cab 20 08-soundly 05-fairly 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 72 5.72 21
Alpine stonebow 85-Lelori 9 li 20 08-soundly 06-decently 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 65 5.0 21
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 no 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 71 5.16 24
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 08-soundly 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 71 5.32 24
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam, cab 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 09-well 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 75 5.8 25
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 li 90 08-soundly 09-well 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 5.0 25
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 no 20 08-soundly 07-reasonably 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 71 5.36 24
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam 20 08-soundly 07-reasonably 09-well 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 71 5.36 24
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam, cab 20 08-soundly 06-decently 09-well 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 75 5.64 23
Alpine stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 li 20 08-soundly 07-reasonably 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 5.0 23
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 no 90 07-reasonably 08-soundly 07-reasonably 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 68 4.6 22
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 lam 90 07-reasonably 08-soundly 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.64 22
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 lam, cab 90 07-reasonably 08-soundly 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 72 5.0 22
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 li 90 07-reasonably 09-well 06-decently 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 65 4.28 22
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 no 20 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 68 4.6 21
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 lam 20 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.58 21
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 lam, cab 20 07-reasonably 06-decently 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 72 5.0 21
Forester's stonebow 85-Lelori 9 li 20 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 65 4.24 21
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 no 90 07-reasonably 09-well 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 71 4.6 23
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam 90 07-reasonably 09-well 07-reasonably 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 71 4.76 23
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam, cab 90 07-reasonably 09-well 08-soundly 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 75 5.0 24
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 li 90 07-reasonably 10-very well 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.36 24
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 no 20 07-reasonably 08-soundly 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 71 4.68 23
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam 20 07-reasonably 08-soundly 08-soundly 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 71 4.68 23
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 lam, cab 20 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 08-soundly 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 75 5.0 22
Forester's stonebow 95-Silverwood 9 li 20 07-reasonably 08-soundly 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.36 22
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 no 90 09-well 07-reasonably 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 76 5.64 24
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 la 90 09-well 07-reasonably 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 76 5.52 24
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 lam, cab 90 09-well 07-reasonably 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 80 6.0 24
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 li 90 09-well 08-soundly 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 73 5.28 24
Battle stonebow 85-Sandalwood 10 no 20 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 114 5,76 23
Battle stonebow 85-Sandalwood 10 la 20 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 114 5.76 23
Battle stonebow 85-Sandalwood 10 lam, cab 20 09-well 05-fairly 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 118 6 23
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 no 15 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 76 5.54 23
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 la 15 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 76 5.54 23
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 lam, cab 15 09-well 05-fairly 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 80 6.0 23
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 no 20 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 76 5.68 23
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 la 20 09-well 06-decently 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 76 5.68 23
Battle stonebow 85-Lelori 10 lam, cab 20 09-well 05-fairly 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 80 6 23
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 no 90 09-well 08-soundly 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 79 5.6 26
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 no 95 09-well 08-soundly (+1) 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 79 5.68 26
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 lam 90 09-well 08-soundly 09-well 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 79 5.64 26
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 lam, cab 90 09-well 07-reasonably 09-well 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 83 6.0 25
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 li 90 09-well 08-soundly 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 76 5.32 25
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 no 20 09-well 06-decently 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 79 5.56 24
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 la 20 09-well 06-decently 09-well 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 79 5.56 24
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 lam, cab 20 09-well 06-decently 10-very well 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 83 6 25
Battle stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 li 20 09-well 07-reasonably 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 76 5.4 25
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 no 90 08-soundly 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 76 5.48 22
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 lam 90 08-soundly 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 76 5.4 22
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 lam, cab 90 08-soundly 07-reasonably 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 80 5.84 23
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 li 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 07-reasonably 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 73 5.0 23
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 no 20 08-soundly 06-decently 08-soundly 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 76 5.36 22
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 lam 20 08-soundly 06-decently 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 76 5.2 22
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 lam, cab 20 08-soundly 05-fairly 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 80 5.52 21
Steppe stonebow 85-Lelori 10 li 20 08-soundly 06-decently 07-reasonably 04-rather flimsy and easily damaged 73 5.0 21
Steppe stonebow 95-Silverwood 10 no 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 79 5.24 24
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 no 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 95 5.32 24
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 lam 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 08-soundly 09-of average construction 95 5.12 24
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 lam, cab 90 08-soundly 08-soundly 09-well 09-of average construction 99 5.64 25
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 li, cab 90 08-soundly 09-well 08-soundly 09-of average construction 92 5.0 25
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 no 20 08-soundly 07-reasonably 09-well 06-somewhat unsound against damage 95 5.28 24
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 lam 20 08-soundly 07-reasonably 09-well 09-of average construction 95 5.36 24
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 lam, cab 20 08-soundly 06-decently 09-well 09-of average construction 99 5.74 23
Steppe stonebow 95-Copperwood 10 li 20 08-soundly 07-reasonably 08-soundly 06-somewhat unsound against damage 92 5.0 23
Slingbow 85-Lelori 8 no 90 06-decently 09-well 06-decently 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 64 4.2 21
Slingbow 85-Lelori 8 lam 90 06-decently 09-well 06-decently 05-particularly weak against damage 64 4.36 21
Slingbow 85-Lelori 8 lam, cab 90 06-decently 08-soundly 07-reasonably 05-particularly weak against damage 68 4.52 21
Slingbow 85-Lelori 8 li 90 06-decently 09-well 06-decently 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 61 4.0 21
Slingbow 85-Sandalwood 8 no 20 06-decently 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 96 4.4 20
Slingbow 85-Sandalwood 8 lam 20 06-decently 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 05-particularly weak against damage 96 4.44 20
Slingbow 85-Sandalwood 8 lam, cab 20 06-decently 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 05-particularly weak against damage 100 4.76 20
Slingbow 85-Sandalwood 8 li 20 06-decently 08-soundly 06-decently 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 93 4.0 20
Slingbow 85-Lelori 8 no 20 06-decently 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 64 4.32 20
Slingbow 85-Lelori 8 li 20 06-decently 08-soundly 06-decently 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 61 4.0 20
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 no 90 06-decently 10-very well 07-reasonably 05-particularly weak against damage 67 4.28 23
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 la 90 06-decently 10-very well 07-reasonably 09-of average construction 67 4.4 23
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 lam, cab 90 06-decently 09-well 07-reasonably 09-of average construction 71 4.52 22
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 li 90 06-decently 10-very well 06-decently 05-particularly weak against damage 64 4.0 22
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 no 20 06-decently 08-soundly 07-reasonably 05-particularly weak against damage 67 4.16 21
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 lam 20 06-decently 08-soundly 07-reasonably 09-of average construction 67 4.24 21
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 lam, cab 20 06-decently 08-soundly 08-soundly 09-of average construction 71 4.72 22
Slingbow 95-Silverwood 8 li 20 06-decently 09-well 07-reasonably 05-particularly weak against damage 64 4.0 22
Slingbow 95-Copperwood 8 lam 20 06-decently 08-soundly 07-reasonably 08-marginally vulnerable 80 4-5 21
Pelletbow 95-Copperwood 9 no 90 06-decently 10-very well 07-reasonably 05-particularly weak against damage 85 4.24 23
Pelletbow 95-Copperwood 9 lam 90 06-decently 10-very well 07-reasonably 09-of average construction 85 4.32 23
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 no 90 06-decently 09-well 06-decently 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 68 4.28 21
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 lam 90 06-decently 09-well 06-decently 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.24 21
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 lam, cab 90 06-decently 08-soundly 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 72 4.76 21
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 li 90 06-decently 09-well 06-decently 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 65 4.0 21
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 no 20 06-decently 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 68 4.24 20
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 lam 20 06-decently 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.44 20
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 lam, cab 20 06-decently 07-reasonably 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 72 4.76 20
Pelletbow 85-Lelori 9 li 20 06-decently 08-soundly 06-decently 03-quite fragile and easily damaged 65 4.0 20
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 no 90 06-decently 10-very well 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 71 4.32 23
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 lam 90 06-decently 10-very well 07-reasonably 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 71 4.24 23
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 lam, cab 90 06-decently 09-well 07-reasonably 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 75 4.68 22
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 li 90 06-decently 10-very well 06-decently 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.0 22
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 no 20 06-decently 08-soundly 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 71 4.4 21
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 lam 20 06-decently 08-soundly 07-reasonably 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 71 4.4 21
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 lam, cab 20 06-decently 08-soundly 08-soundly 10-a bit safeguarded against damage 75 4.52 22
Pelletbow 95-Silverwood 9 li 20 06-decently 09-well 07-reasonably 06-somewhat unsound against damage 68 4.0 22
Retrieved from "https://elanthipedia.play.net/index.php?title=Dreamheart/Comparison_Chart_of_Stonebows&oldid=544064"