Talk:Xerasyth: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
As the player of one of the characters in question, I'm personally not at all comfortable with the way this is currently worded. I think it doesn't delineate between the parts of the article that are known ICly and the parts (namely those involving my character and Seb) which are not known ICly. Like Ysselt was saying, the only thing that is known in game is that Khurek has accused Sebastienne and Ignifera of spying for Xerasyth on Sothavi's meeting in Shard regarding tactics to stop/kill him and the other Adan'f who had been invading Shard. If people feel the need to include information that is not known in game, it should be specifically identified as such, in order to keep people from making metagaming mistakes. To be honest, things like this make me all that more hesitant to post non-public event information. Please change it. |
As the player of one of the characters in question, I'm personally not at all comfortable with the way this is currently worded. I think it doesn't delineate between the parts of the article that are known ICly and the parts (namely those involving my character and Seb) which are not known ICly. Like Ysselt was saying, the only thing that is known in game is that Khurek has accused Sebastienne and Ignifera of spying for Xerasyth on Sothavi's meeting in Shard regarding tactics to stop/kill him and the other Adan'f who had been invading Shard. If people feel the need to include information that is not known in game, it should be specifically identified as such, in order to keep people from making metagaming mistakes. To be honest, things like this make me all that more hesitant to post non-public event information. Please change it. |
||
--[[User:Ignifera|Ignifera]] 16:53, 13 September 2009 (UTC) |
--[[User:Ignifera|Ignifera]] 16:53, 13 September 2009 (UTC) |
||
:I posted what is known, with Seb's permission no less. You're free to clarify further within the article. We are not doing the Natashya song and dance again. [[User:Reene|Reene]] 18:23, 13 September 2009 (UTC) |
|||
Revision as of 12:23, 13 September 2009
We may want to add something, because information about Sebastienne and Ignifera helping Xerasyth is only knowledge from the forums. I'm afraid that by posting it here like this without any type of disclaimer, people will be apt to assume it is known in-game. While Khurek DID claim they helped (by SPYING only) on the Crossing gweth, its only speculation if that's true or not, and the article may want to reflect that as well (edited) Thoughts? --Ysselt 16:23, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
As the player of one of the characters in question, I'm personally not at all comfortable with the way this is currently worded. I think it doesn't delineate between the parts of the article that are known ICly and the parts (namely those involving my character and Seb) which are not known ICly. Like Ysselt was saying, the only thing that is known in game is that Khurek has accused Sebastienne and Ignifera of spying for Xerasyth on Sothavi's meeting in Shard regarding tactics to stop/kill him and the other Adan'f who had been invading Shard. If people feel the need to include information that is not known in game, it should be specifically identified as such, in order to keep people from making metagaming mistakes. To be honest, things like this make me all that more hesitant to post non-public event information. Please change it. --Ignifera 16:53, 13 September 2009 (UTC)
- I posted what is known, with Seb's permission no less. You're free to clarify further within the article. We are not doing the Natashya song and dance again. Reene 18:23, 13 September 2009 (UTC)